Which car should I buy: Jetta (Comfortline) 2.0 L, Corolla, or Civic?

I am buying a new car and have narrowed it down to three models: The Jetta (Comfortline) 2.0 L, Corolla, and Civic. I am looking for power, fuel efficiency, quality, reliability, good handling, resale opportunity, and the "coolness factor." Thanks